A class action lawsuit has been filed against Apple, alleging that some Apple Watch wristbands contain potentially hazardous levels of harmful chemicals.
PFAS, also known as "forever chemicals," are commonly found in everyday products, from nonstick pans to drinking water, and have been linked to serious health issues, including prostate and kidney cancer and pregnancy complications. Manufacturers use PFAS due to their affordability and wide availability. Currently, there are no federal safety regulations for PFAS, except in drinking water.
The lawsuit, filed in the United States District Court of Northern California, claims that three Apple Watch bands -- the Sport Band, Ocean Band, and Nike Sport Band -- contain harmful levels of PFAS to make them resistant to sweat and skin oils. It cites a recent study by the University of Notre Dame, which identified these wristbands as having elevated PFAS levels.
The lawsuit alleges that Apple was aware of the toxic chemical levels but chose not to use safer materials like silicone to keep costs down. It argues that consumers purchase smartwatches to monitor and improve their health daily, expecting them to be safe, especially since they are typically worn for 11 or more hours each day.
In a statement to CNET, an Apple spokesperson said: "Apple Watch bands are safe for users to wear. In addition to our own testing, we also work with independent laboratories to conduct rigorous testing and analysis of the materials used in our products, including Apple Watch bands."
In 2022, the company committed to phasing out PFAS and has helped lead the industry in removing potentially harmful chemicals from its products and manufacturing processes. Apple told CNET that its material safety standards often exceed regulatory requirements to protect human health and the environment.
The study also examined bands from other brands, including Fitbit and Samsung, but the specific findings remain unclear. However, the lawsuit points to Google's Pixel Watch Woven Band (made of recycled yarn) and Fitbit's Sport Band (made of silicone) as potential PFAS-free alternatives.
The lawsuit seeks refunds for people who overpaid due to alleged misleading claims and asks the court to prohibit Apple from making false advertising statements or selling these products without proper disclosures.